Best Rarest Beanie Boos

20.9k reviews scanned and analysysed
David Murphy
David Murphy Writer
Last Updated: Oct 22, 2024 Share On:

What is the best rarest beanie boo of 2024? We analyzed 95 related products and 20871 reviews to come up with this list, and we found that most products were from brands such as Ty, and Yuanpulalala. The prices range from $5.5 to $13.48, and most consumers would pay around $11.

We found sellers like Yuanpu ( 3.37 / 5 ), The Daily Buyer ( 4.82 / 5 ), and Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 ) offer these products. After a thorough comparison, we pick "TY 36284" as our top choice. Check out our recommendations before you buy.

A Quick Look: Our Top Picks

Top 1
Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos
9.8We rank the products based on a number of factors such as features, price, customer reviews and so on.

Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos

Read More Check Price
Top 1 Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos

Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos

Read More Check Price
Top 2
Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal
9.7We rank the products based on a number of factors such as features, price, customer reviews and so on.

Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal

Read More Check Price
Top 2 Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal

Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal

Read More Check Price
Top 3
Ty 37350 Beanie Boo Licorice The Black Cat
9.4We rank the products based on a number of factors such as features, price, customer reviews and so on.

Ty 37350 Beanie Boo Licorice The Black Cat

Read More Check Price
Top 3 Ty 37350 Beanie Boo Licorice The Black Cat

Ty 37350 Beanie Boo Licorice The Black Cat

Read More Check Price

*Note The result is based on our independent research, and we are reader-supported and do not promote any brand or retailer. As a member of Amazon Marketing Affiliates, we may receive a commission from qualified purchases.

Top 20 Rarest Beanie Boos Reviews 2024 In Detail

1 Editor's Choice

Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos

TYBrand 36284Model 3.49H*1.41L*1.39W inchesDimension
Ranked #18 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos cover
Ty 36284 15 Cm Giselle Leopard W/Horn-Beanie Boos thumb #1
9.8We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Save 16% + FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » IzzyBeez ( 4.95 / 5 )
Features
  • The new Ty line in a retro look
  • Collectable item.
  • Over 40 different designs
  • Glitter eyes.
  • The original
2 Editor's Choice

Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal

TYBrand 36368Model 2.17H*1.24L*1.09W inchesDimension 0.2 lbWeight
Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal cover
Ty 36368 2007520 Atlas Fox Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal thumb #1
9.7We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Beanie Boos Atlas is a 15 cm tall fox
  • Funkelnde Glitzeraugen und super glitzernde Texturen
  • Made from super soft TY silk fabric
  • Atlass birthday is on July 7th
  • This product contains - 1 x TY Beanie Boo's - Fox Atlas - 15 CM
3 Editor's Choice

Ty 37350 Beanie Boo Licorice The Black Cat

TYBrand 37350Model 6.0H*3.0L*2.0W inchesDimension
Ranked #2 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ranked #4 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 37350 Beanie Boo Licorice The Black Cat cover
9.4We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 )
Features
  • Black Cat for Halloween 2024
4

Ty 37351 Beanie Boo Ooooky The White Ghost

TYBrand 37351Model 6.0H*3.0L*2.0W inchesDimension
Ranked #8 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 37351 Beanie Boo Ooooky The White Ghost cover
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Save 6% + FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 )
Features
  • White Ghost for Halloween 2024
5

Ty 37352 Beanie Boo Godfrey The Black And Tan Spider

TYBrand 37352Model 6.0H*3.0L*2.0W inchesDimension
Ranked #3 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ranked #7 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 37352 Beanie Boo Godfrey The Black And Tan Spider cover
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 )
Features
  • New Black/Tan Spider 2024
6

Ty 36249 2007517 Muddles Brown & White Dog Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal

TYBrand 36249Model 5.51H*3.15L*2.76W inchesDimension 0.2 lbWeight
Ranked #9 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 36249 2007517 Muddles Brown & White Dog Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal cover
Ty 36249 2007517 Muddles Brown & White Dog Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal thumb #1Ty 36249 2007517 Muddles Brown & White Dog Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal thumb #2
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $
Save 31%
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » The Daily Buyer ( 4.82 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Beanie Boos Muddles is a 15 cm tall dog
  • Schimmernde Glitzeraugen und super glitzernde Texturen
  • Made from super soft TY silk fabric
  • Muddles' birthday is on July 22nd
  • This product contains - 1 x TY Beanie Boo's - Dog Muddles - 15 CM
7

Ty 37349 Beanie Boo Batrick The Black Halloween Bat

TYBrand 37349Model 6.0H*3.0L*2.0W inchesDimension
Ranked #6 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 37349 Beanie Boo Batrick The Black Halloween Bat cover
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Save 6% + FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 )
Features
  • Halloween Bat for 2024
8

Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal

TYBrand 36366Model 2.17H*1.24L*1.09W inchesDimension 0.15 lbWeight
Ranked #3 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ranked #6 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal cover
Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal thumb #1Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal thumb #2Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal thumb #3Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal thumb #4Ty 36366 2007516 Fiona Cat Beanie Boo Pink Stuffed Animal thumb #5
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Save 25% + FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Novelty Shop ( 4.92 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Beanie Boos Fiona is a 15 cm pink cat
  • Schimmernde Glitzeraugen und super glitzernde Texturen
  • Made from super soft TY silk fabric
  • Fiona's birthday is on February 1st
  • This product contains - 1 x TY Beanie Boo's - Pink Cat Fiona - 15 CM
9

Ty T37363 Beanie Boos Coco The Leopard

TYBrand T37363Model 5.91H*3.15L*3.15W inchesDimension
Ranked #10 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ranked #11 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ty T37363 Beanie Boos Coco The Leopard cover
Ty T37363 Beanie Boos Coco The Leopard thumb #1
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 )
Features
  • New release for Fall 2024
10

Ty 41506 Beanie Bellie Victor The Halloween Monster

TYBrand 41506Model 6.0H*3.0L*2.0W inchesDimension
Ranked #5 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ranked #13 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 41506 Beanie Bellie Victor The Halloween Monster cover
9.0We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Novelty Shop ( 4.92 / 5 )
Features
  • Orange Pumpkin figure for Halloween 2024
11

Ty 41510 Beanie Bellies Alex The Pastel Axolotl

TYBrand 41510Model 5.51H*2.76L*3.15W inchesDimension
Ranked #15 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 41510 Beanie Bellies Alex The Pastel Axolotl cover
8.8We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 )
Features
  • New Fall 2024 Release
12

Ty TY36376 2008069 Beanie Boos 15 Cm-T36376 Opal Plush Toy

TYBrand TY36376Model 5.91H*2.76L*2.76W inchesDimension 0.2 lbWeight
Ranked #1 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ty TY36376 2008069 Beanie Boos 15 Cm-T36376 Opal Plush Toy cover
8.8We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Beanie Boo's Opal is a 15 cm tall cat
  • Opal has a beautiful green with pink fur and glitter eyes and legs
  • Opal's birthday is April 13th
  • You can take this friend with you everywhere
  • This product contains - 1 x TY Beanie Boo's - Cat Opal - 15 CM
13

Ty 36225 Uk Ltd 2005069 Phoenix Fox - Beanie Boos Stuffed Animal

TYBrand 36225Model 5.91H*7.87L*3.94W inchesDimension 0.2 lbWeight
Ty 36225 Uk Ltd 2005069 Phoenix Fox - Beanie Boos Stuffed Animal cover
Ty 36225 Uk Ltd 2005069 Phoenix Fox - Beanie Boos Stuffed Animal thumb #1Ty 36225 Uk Ltd 2005069 Phoenix Fox - Beanie Boos Stuffed Animal thumb #2
8.6We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Save 5% + FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Novelty Shop ( 4.92 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Beanie Boos Phoenix is a 15 cm tall white fox
  • Schimmernde Glitzeraugen und super glitzernde Texturen
  • Made from super soft TY silk fabric
  • Fox Phoenix's birthday is September 18th
  • This product contains - 1 x TY Beanie Boo's - Fox Phoenix - 15 CM
14

Ty 36365 2007519 Nina Mouse With Tutu Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal

TYBrand 36365Model 5.51H*3.15L*2.76W inchesDimension 0.18 lbWeight
Ranked #19 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ranked #20 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ty 36365 2007519 Nina Mouse With Tutu Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal cover
Ty 36365 2007519 Nina Mouse With Tutu Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal thumb #1Ty 36365 2007519 Nina Mouse With Tutu Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal thumb #2Ty 36365 2007519 Nina Mouse With Tutu Beanie Boo Stuffed Animal thumb #3
8.4We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $
Save 46%
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » iagarcia ( 4.76 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Beanie Boos Nina is a 15 cm tall mouse
  • Schimmernde Glitzeraugen und super glitzernde Texturen
  • Made from super soft TY silk fabric
  • Nina's birthday is September 22nd
  • This product contains - 1 x TY Beanie Boo's - Mouse Nina - 15 CM
15

Yuanpulalala TY PLUSH Beanie Boo Scrappy Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Doll 6Inch

YUANPULALALABrand Ty plushModel 4.0H*2.0L*1.5W inchesDimension
Ranked #14 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Yuanpulalala TY PLUSH Beanie Boo Scrappy Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Doll 6Inch cover
8.2We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Yuanpu ( 3.37 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Stuffed Animals Plush Doll
16

Ty 37345 Beanie Boo Ethel - Spotted Purple Cow

TYBrand 37345Model 5.91H*3.15L*3.54W inchesDimension
Ranked #9 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ranked #17 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ty 37345 Beanie Boo Ethel - Spotted Purple Cow cover
8.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 )
Features
  • Approximately 6 inch tall
17

Ty 36581 Beanie Boos Fergus The Cat

TYBrand 36581Model 6.0H*3.25L*3.0W inchesDimension 0.2 lbWeight
Ty 36581 Beanie Boos Fergus The Cat cover
8.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 )
Features
  • Beanie Boo's is the line of soft plush toys with big colourful and glittery eyes inspired by the world of animals, nature or fantasy, all to collect
  • A beautiful TY Beanie Boss plush toy in the shape of a kitten;Made with great attention to detail Super soft with big glittery eyes - the real original plush TY
  • Name - Fergus;Fitted with the authentic Ty heart-shaped name tag with the name and date of birth
  • Colour - grey, white; with green glitter eyes Size - 15 cm
  • Great gift idea for birthday or anniversary or for any occasion Great toys to win the hearts of children, teenagers and why not, even the oldest
18

Ty 37318 Beanie Boos - Hambo The Cute Pig

TYBrand 37318Model 6.0H*3.5L*5.0W inchesDimension
Ty 37318 Beanie Boos - Hambo The Cute Pig cover
8.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 )
Features
  • Beanie Boo's is the line of soft plush toys with big colourful and glittery eyes inspired by the world of animals, nature or fantasy, all to collect!
  • A beautiful TY Beanie Boss plush toy in the shape of a pig. Made with great attention to detail. Super soft with big glittery eyes - the real original plush TY!
  • Name - Hambo Date of birth - -. Featuring an authentic Ty heart shaped name and date of birth.
  • Colour - pink, grey. With blue glitter eyes! Size - 15 cm.
  • Great gift idea for birthday or anniversary or for any occasion! The perfect toy to win the hearts of children, teenagers and why not, even the oldest!
19

Ty 36691 Boo Animals Beanie Boo'S-Plush Cobalt The Leopard 15Cm-Ty36691

TYBrand 36691Model 0.0H*0.0L*0.0W inchesDimension 0.2 lbWeight
Ranked #14 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Muffins Of 2024
Ranked #17 in Best Ty Beanie Boos Friends Forever Plushes Of 2024
Ty 36691 Boo Animals Beanie Boo'S-Plush Cobalt The Leopard 15Cm-Ty36691 cover
7.9We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Good Price: $$
Save 15% + FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 )
Features
  • Adorable beige, blue and white leopard in realistic plush 15cm tall.
  • Ultra trendy and irresistible with its extremely soft fur, large shiny eyes and ears, this plush is suitable for young and teenagers and older children.
  • Many other collectible animals in the Beanie Boo's range, in sizes 15cm, 23cm and 41cm, and key rings.
  • FEATURES - Contains 1 leopard plush. Plush Dimensions - Length 8.5cm x Width 7cm x Height 15cm Material(s) used - Polyester (fibers), Plastic (balls). Recommended age range - from 3 years old
  • Birthday date - April 27
20

Yuanpulalala TY PLUSH Beanie Baby Prince Dog Stuffed Animal Plush Doll

YUANPULALALABrand Ty plushModel 6.0H*6.0L*3.0W inchesDimension
Yuanpulalala TY PLUSH Beanie Baby Prince Dog Stuffed Animal Plush Doll cover
Yuanpulalala TY PLUSH Beanie Baby Prince Dog Stuffed Animal Plush Doll thumb #1Yuanpulalala TY PLUSH Beanie Baby Prince Dog Stuffed Animal Plush Doll thumb #2
7.7We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Good Price: $$
FreeShipping
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Yuanpu ( 3.37 / 5 )
Features
  • Ty Prince Dog Stuffed Animals Plush Doll
  • Size - about 6in (15cm)
  • Material - Environmental Protection Plush
  • Feature Of Product - 1. Super cute animal images, very popular with children, the best choice for gifts. 2. Healthy and environmentally friendly production materials, let your children play freely without worry. 3. Excellent quality, long service life, it can be a good memory of children's childhood. 4. Big shiny eyes, very cute, loved by adults and children

Best Rarest Beanie Boos Of 2024 Rating

Top Reviewed Rarest Beanie Boos

Popular Related

FAQ & Notes

David Murphy Written By David Murphy

During our research, we found more than 95 related products, with prices ranging from $5.5 to $13.48, and most customers would pay around $11 for this type of product.

What are the top brands of Rarest Beanie Boos?

There are 2 brands available for Rarest Beanie Boos, such as Yuanpulalala, Ty.

What are the available sellers for Rarest Beanie Boos?

There are 7 sellers available for Rarest Beanie Boos, including NevarProducts ( 4.83 / 5 ), Yuanpu ( 3.37 / 5 ), Novelty Shop ( 4.92 / 5 ), Johnathan's Place ( 4.89 / 5 ), The Daily Buyer ( 4.82 / 5 ), IzzyBeez ( 4.95 / 5 ), iagarcia ( 4.76 / 5 ).

Price comparison of the top 10 Rarest Beanie Boos

*Note: Prices based on historical data.

Price comparison of the top 10 Rarest Beanie Boos highly recommended

*Note: Prices based on historical data.

The Verdict

After thorough consideration, we have selected the product TY 36284 as your preferred option.

As an alternative, we have also compiled a list based on user reviews, and the product TY 36225 is also worthy of your purchase.